Ditching Gmail After 15 Years

Gmail Logo

Everyone who even casually follows the tech industry knows, intellectually, that Google builds an enormous dystopian profile of everything you do in order to sell ads1. But I think there's a difference between knowing that Google Analytics is a shameless back door to do cross-site tracking and actually coming face-to-face with your own profile. Yesterday, CNBC featured a story about a new Google UI which shows you a list of every purchase that you've made in the last few years: https://myaccount.google.com/purchases. For me, wide variety of commercial activity — every purchase I've ever made at a store that uses Square, every Amazon purchase, every Apple purchase, every movie ticket. I see gifts for my wife, work purchases, and even food for my rabbits. And on almost every item is a note: This purchase was found in your Gmail.

It's been clear for a long time that Google as a company no longer considers their users to be much more than piñatas full of delicious data; for me, seeing that list of the last 7+ years of every purchase I've made electronically is the last straw. As of today, I'm taking my personal domain (roguelazer.com) off of the grandfathered free-tier Gsuite2 mail hosting that it's had for the last 10+ years and moving it to a host that seems less inclined to aggressively mine it for data, and moving as many accounts as possible to no longer depend on my gmail.com account. I opened my Gmail account 15 years ago3, so I guess it's time to move on.

I went through the current crop of mail hosts, and evaluated them against the following conditions:

  • I don't want to self-host; I have no interest in actually maintaining (and monitoring and backing up) an SMTP and IMAP server. I get enough of my day job at my day job.
  • I prefer to use regular IMAP and SMTP protocols and mail clients (e.g., mutt); anything that requires that you use the provider's custom application is right out.
  • I'd like a hosting provider who's been around for a few years and seems unlikely to vanish off the face of the Earth tomorrow
  • Decent performance from the US

After doing some research, I decided that Fastmail was the least-worst option4. So I've migrated all my mail out of Gsuite onto Fastmail, re-pointed my MX records, and configured Gsuite to route any mails that still trickle into it over to Fastmail. Some time tomorrow when all the TTLs have expired, I will be shutting down my Gsuite account5.

If you want to have a chance in hell that our grandkids won't live in a surveillance dystopia, search with DuckDuckGo, close your Gmail account, switch to Firefox, and remind your elected officials that the world would be a better place without Big Data.


"Google Apps for Your Domain" when I signed up for it in 2007...


August 12, 2004. What a different time.


Yes, I've already had Protonmail recommended to me by a half-dozen people. I've tried it, but it misses half my criteria and at this point I think anyone pushing a commercial VPN as a product for any reason is probably a snake-oil salesman.


Don't worry, I used the helpful Google Takeout tool to dump out an .mbox of my mail for historical purposes.

Want to comment on this? How about we talk on Mastodon instead? mastodon logo Share on Mastodon